"Having a great time with V-Rally 4 here.
It's no Dirt/Richard Burns/etc but the basics of a fun rally game are there. (it also has a couple of other disciplines which I haven't touched yet)
The only other racing games I have on the Switch are the first Gear.Club Unlimited and MotoGP 18.
It's light-years ahead of Gear.Club Unlimited - especially when it comes to car control/feeling. (don't have GCU 2 so don't know how it compares to that)
Performance is good, cars control well (if a little twitchy), good camera options (cockpit,bonnet,etc), it has full replays and I'm really digging its' sound design/effects.
No analog triggers is also a non-issue. Once you "get" how much brake/gas you need to apply to throw the car into a corner, you'll be using the brake/gas buttons without even thinking about it.
Don't expect graphics to blow you away (and at moments it can look ugly tbh), but if that's a big deal to you watch some videos to get some idea of what you are getting into.
I honestly don't mind them one bit and to be honest they have a certain charm. (oh and I got used to the shadow-drawing "issue" on some tracks/times-of-day pretty fast)
The only negative point I can think of, is the game's attempt to make you have an active role in building your team. You are supposed to hire mechanics, agents, etc something I honestly don't care about - I just want to race so I ignore this part as much as I can.
Anyways, just my two cents in case anyone wants to scratch that rally itch on the Switch.
I know that it didn't review too favorably on other platforms, but it has Forzas and Grand Tourismos to compete against there - I just know I'm having fun with it on Switch and that's all that matters. "