GOTY Awards 2007

[tweaker06]

ich dachte mir das wir einen thread brauchen, in dem alle goty auszeichnungen auf einen blick zu sehen sind. der "spike goty" thread ist sehr unübersichtlich.

hier die bisherigen goty verleihungen

SPIKE TV

GAME OF THE YEAR BioShock

STUDIO OF THE YEAR
Harmonix

BEST SHOOTER
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (Activision/ Infinity Ward)

BEST RPG
Mass Effect (Microsoft Game Studios/ BioWare)

BEST MILITARY GAME
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (Activision/ Infinity Ward)

BEST INDIVIDUAL SPORTS GAME
skate (Electronic Arts/ EA Black Box)

BEST HANDHELD GAME
The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass (Nintendo/ Nintendo)

BEST GRAPHICS
Crysis (Electronic Arts/ Crytek)

BEST GAME BASED ON A MOVIE OR TV SHOW
The Simpsons Game (Electronic Arts/ EA Redwood Shores)

BEST RHYTHM GAME
Rock Band (MTV Games/ Harmonix)

BEST DRIVING GAME
DiRT (Codemasters/ Codemasters)

BEST ACTION GAME
Super Mario Galaxy (Nintendo/ Nintendo)

BEST TEAM SPORTS GAME
Madden NFL 08 (Electronic Arts/ EA Tiburon)

BEST SOUNDTRACK
Rock Band (MTV Games/ Harmonix)

BREAKTHROUGH TECHNOLOGY
The Orange Box/ Portal (Valve/ Valve)

BEST XBOX 360 GAME
BioShock

BEST WII GAME
Super Mario Galaxy (Nintendo/ Nintendo)

BEST PS3 GAME
Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction (Sony Computer Entertainment/
Insomniac Games)

BEST PC GAME
The Orange Box (Valve/ Valve)

BEST ORIGINAL SCORE
BioShock

BEST MULTI-PLAYER GAME
Halo 3 (Microsoft Game Studios/ Bungie Studios)

MOST ADDICTIVE VIDEO GAME FUELED BY DEW
Halo 3 (Microsoft Game Studios/ Bungie Studios)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Time Magazin

1.Halo 3

2.The Orange Box
3.Rock Band
4.Super Mario Galaxy
5.BioShock
6.Call of Duty 4
7.Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass
8.Mass Effect
9.Ace Combat 6: Fires of Liberation
10.God of War 2

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Edge Awards 2007

Best Game

SMG
Runners-Up
The Orange Box
Halo 3

Best Innovation

Halo 3
Runners-Up
Crysis
Portal

Best Visual Design

Bioshock
Runners-Up
Team Fortress 2
SMG

Best Audio Design

SMG
Runners-Up
Halo 3
Colin MCrae: Dirt

Best Online Experience

Halo 3
Runners-Up
Forza 2
Wii Channels

Best Hardware

Rock Band
Runners-Up
Nintendo DS
Nintendo Wii

Best Developer

Valve
Runners-Up
Bungie
Nintendo

Best Publisher

Nintendo
Runners-Up
Microsoft
EA

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

next-gen.biz GOTY

10. Pac-Man Championship Edition—XBLA
Namco Bandai
6/6/07

This one almost completely blindsided us. What more could’ve been done with Pac-Man, and why should anyone care about a a game that's a direct descendent of its low-fi 1980 arcade forebear? Pac-Man CE answers this simply by adding a time limit and changing the way level progression works. Elegant in its simplicity, the new formula works to great effect. Twenty-seven years after Pac-Man’s introduction, creator Tooru Iwatani managed to show that the real Pac-Man—not the one that runs around 3D worlds or drives go-karts—is still the man.




9.World of Warcraft: The Burning Crusade—PC
Vivendi Games, Blizzard
1/16/07

World of Warcraft’s first expansion was a critical and commercial smash, and we had little reason to expect anything othewise. Hordes of gamers snatched up The Burning Crusade when it launched in January—2.4 million of them. On day one. The game upped the level cap to 70 and added gorgeous new environments helping drive the user base of the game over 1 million players throughout the course of 2007 to over 9.3 million. We can hardly imagine the kind of impact that the upcoming expansion Wrath of the Lich King will have on the international games industry.





8.God of War II—PS2
SCEA
3/13/07

In March this year, amidst all of the “next-generation” hype, God of War II released on the incomparable old timer, PS2. And Kratos’ latest managed to mercilessly beat down many of the so-called next-generation action games that released in 2007. God of War II improves upon 2005’s God of War in every conceivable way, adding more bosses, more mind-sharpening puzzles and more sheer brutality. Being near-perfect, it will appropriately be remembered as the last great game for PS2.





7.The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass—DS
Nintendo
10/1/07

The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass is actually the first Zelda game for the three-year-old Nintendo DS. Now that it has finally arrived, most everyone can agree that this sequel to the GameCube’s Wind Waker was worth the wait. Intuitive controls, endearing cartoonish graphics and an engrossing adventure make Phantom Hourglass a must for Zelda fans and one of the best entry points for newcomers to the classic series.





6. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare—PC, Xbox 360, PS3
Activision, Infinity Ward
11/5/07

The Call of Duty series is back in top form with Infinity Ward at the helm. Call of Duty 4’s single-player story mode is very short, but plenty of surprises and razor-edge execution more than make up for the length. As excellent as the single player mode is, it’s the multiplayer that’s the main draw here. A compelling class system and a groundbreaking reward system for consecutive kills (two consecutive kills improves radar capabilities, five-kills lets you call in an air-strike, etc.) will keep the 2 million Americans that have bought this game so far coming back again and again. Oh, and the graphics are some of the best you’ll find on consoles.





5.Halo 3—Xbox 360
Microsoft, Bungie
9/25/07

It’s pretty rare that any sort of trilogy can maintain a high level of quality throughout all three entries, but Bungie pulled it off in 2007 with the release of Halo 3. Gameplay is tighter than ever and the white-knuckle multiplayer modes are plentiful. The Forge and Save Films features push console shooters to new heights and integration with Bungie.net fosters an already strong community. Four-player online co-op for the campaign mode turns out to be one of the best multiplayer experiences around. And the game’s story is a satisfying culmination of all of the Halo mythology that has been expressed in everything from books to graphic novels, and of course, Halo 1 and 2. Hands-down, the best game in the series, which says a lot. $300 million in global week-one sales prove that Master Chief's draw is as powerful as ever.





4.The Orange Box—PC, Xbox 360, PS3
EA, Valve
10/10/07 (PC, Xbox 360); 12/11/07 (PS3)

We’re kind of glad that Valve and EA decided to put all of these great games in one package, not only because it’s likely the best deal in gaming right now, but also so we have an excuse to wedge all of these top-tier games into one slot. Everyone knows that 2004’s Half-Life 2 is one of the best examples of the FPS genre, and 2006’s Episode One was icing on the cake. New, though, is the raucous Team Fortress 2, with its comically gory style and gameplay that expertly adheres to the playing style of virtually anyone. And then there’s Portal, a mind-bending game that took the portal mechanics used in 2006’s Prey to entirely new levels. And Half-Life 2: Episode Two is the best entry into the saga yet. We’re not sure how this package could possibly be any better outside of including a free functional Aperture Science Handheld Portal Device with every purchase.





3.BioShock—PC, Xbox 360
2K Games, 2K Boston
8/21/07

BioShock would be prime material for a videogame lit. course. It’s inspired by the work of writer and philosopher Ayn Rand and explores ideas surrounding ethics, politics, metaphysics, genetics and perhaps one or two more ‘ics. This is a game whose events you almost want transcribed on paper so that you can examine at leisure the various intertwining themes that are presented in-game through vehicles like the Big Daddy, Little Sisters, Adam, plasmids and splicers. And there are tons of tape recordings strewn about the watery **** called Rapture that dot its hyper-atmospheric hallways, nearly all of which are worth listening to. But don’t get us wrong—this is a shooter, and an innovative one at that, encouraging players to experiment with different killing tactics. BioShock contains the best examples of emergent gameplay this year. Look beyond the nearly flawless gameplay execution and you’ll realize that the themes explored in BioShock are perhaps more interesting than the game itself. Color us thrilled that the game sold well enough to warrant a sequel.


2.Rock Band—Xbox 360, PS3, PS2
MTV Games, EA, Harmonix
11/20/07

We were hard-pressed to think of any games that we had more fun with in 2007 than Rock Band. This game is inherently social and hands-down the best multiplayer experience this year. It’s also a supremely addictive game that is completely accessible where it wants to be and tough as all hell if you’re into digital masochism. Thinking back on Rock Band, we’re kind of surprised that it took this long for someone to combine all of these instruments into one cohesive package. But we’re exceedingly grateful that the musical mavericks at Harmonix were the ones to take the initiative and create a game that we’ll continue to play into the wee hours of the morning for many sessions to come.

1.Super Mario Galaxy—Wii
Nintendo
12/12/07

It’s hard to describe the sheer joy that Super Mario Galaxy elicits. At times, this game plays the player. It plays with your sense of direction, your sense of space and your sense of what’s possible in this narrow genre that we define as “platforming.” But Super Mario Galaxy flies in the face of preconceived notions. While the game gifts the player with a wide spectrum of advancements and fresh concepts, it remains remarkably accessible. Don’t be mistaken by that accessibility though, because there is ample challenge for more avid players. It’s a high water mark for videogame design and a shining example of what this medium is capable of, which is why it’s Next-Gen’s 2007 Game of the Year.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Wired GOTY

10) Crackdown
9) Desktop Tower Defense
Crysis
7) CoD4
6) Mass Effect
5) Legend of Zelda: PH
4) Orange Box
3) Bioshock
2) Super Mario Galaxy

1) Rock Band

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1up-Wahlen zum GOTY:

What’s your pick for 2007 Game of the Year?

WINNER = SUPER MARIO GALAXY

Mass Effect (11%)
Uncharted: Drake’s Fortune (5%)
The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass (1%)
Halo 3 (8%)
Bioshock (16%)
Super Mario Galaxy (24%)
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (10%)
Rock Band (2%)
Metroid Prime 3: Corruption (1%)
The Orange Box (23%)

Total Votes: 1771

What game do you think most media outlets will pick for 2007 Game of the Year?

WINNER = HALO 3
Metroid Prime 3: Corruption (0%)
Halo 3 (35%)
Bioshock (18%)
Mass Effect (1%)
The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass (0%)
Uncharted: Drake’s Fortune (1%)
The Orange Box (10%)
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (6%)
Super Mario Galaxy (27%)
Rock Band (2%)

Total Votes: 1624

What’s your pick for 2007 Platform of the Year?

WINNER = XBOX 360

Xbox (0%)
GameCube (0%)
Wii (16%)
Game Boy Advance (0%)
PlayStation 3 (9%)
PC (8%)
PlayStation 2 (1%)
Xbox 360 (58%)
Nintendo DS (6%)
PSP (1%)

Total Votes: 1645

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Gamespy Awards

PS3 GOTY: Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
PC: Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
360: Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
DS: The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass
GBA: Final Fantasy VI Advance
PSP: FF Tactics: The War of the Lions
PS2: God of War II
Wii: Super Mario Galaxy

Multiplayer
10. Puzzle league planet
9. Motorstorm
8. Forza 2
7. VF5 online
6. Wowhawk
5. World in Conflict
4. Halo 3
3. Rock Band
2. COD4
1. Team Forttress 2

Special Awards
Rookie Dev: Real Time Worlds (Crackdown)
Best XBLA: Puzzle Quest
Best PSN: Everyday shooter
Best Wii VC: Sin and Punishment
Best Puzzle: Portal
Best Sports: Skate
Best Soundtrack: Mass Erect
Over-Under Achievement Awards...Avatar The Air Bender
Rookie Robocop: Crackdown
Best Voice Acting: Mass Erect
Game that makes us treat out guitar like Who: Rock band
Worst thing ever done to a videogame GF: Darkness
Unique Art Style: TF2
Best License Use: LOTRO
Worst License Use: Shadow Run
Best Art Direction: Bioshock
best sound: Bioshock
Best Graphics: Call of Duty 4
Best character: Glados
Best Sidekick: Companion Cube
Best developer: Infinity Ward
Best story: Bioshock
Innovation on Wii: MP3
Best Trend: Community Integration
Worst Trend: Lousy hardward
Dissapointment: Vangaurd
When it's done award: Warhammer Online
Suprise of the Year: The Witcher

Reader's Choice
PS2: GOW2
PS3: Uncharted
360: Mass Effect
Wii: Mario
DS: Zelda
PSP: FFT
PCAction: Orange Box
PCRPG: WoW BC
PSSports/Racingirt
PCRTS: World in Conflict
PCMP:TF2
PCOverall: Orange Box

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Gamereactor GOTY

1. SMG

2. Crysis
3. Mass Effect
4. Orange Box
5. Halo3
6. Bioshock
7. FFXII (european release in 2007)
8. CoD4
9. Zelda PH
10. World in conflict

http://www.gamereactor.se/artiklar/1...ets+spel+2007/

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

sollten weitere dazukommen werde ich sie rein editieren

 

[Naked_Snake100]

Also SMG liegt danach ganz klar vorne mit 4 Stimmen, danach folgen Bioshock, Halo 3 und Rock Band mit jeweils einer. (rein von den GOTY's Wahlen ausgehend)

 

[Wandhydrant]

Ich würde sagen: ziemlich verdient. Ich kann fast alle Wertungen sehr gut nachvollziehen.

 

[Vischnu]

sehr gute idee! endlich alle gotys auf einen blick und nicht endlose sucherei.


PS: nächste woche kommt das 4players.de goty

 

[sebi88]

Alles recht ordentlich bisher.

Edge müsste mir nur mal den Innovations Award für Halo 3 erklären^^

 

[Krogan]

News from the virtual world:

— BEST OF 2007: It has been a terrific year for video games, and boiling it down to a top 10 list was difficult. But here are the games I enjoyed the most in 2007.

1. "BioShock": My AP colleague Matt Slagle called it the game of the year, and I have no argument. Ken Levine's undersea epic combines a thought-provoking story, compelling gameplay, dazzling visuals and a lush soundtrack to create one of gaming's true masterpieces.

2. "Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction": Everyone's favorite lombax-robot team returns in this delightful space-faring romp. The animation is movie-quality; the action, whether you're swinging between platforms or blowing up aliens, is consistently satisfying.

3. "Super Mario Galaxy": Just about every planet Mario visits in his latest adventure provides a new kind of challenge, giving "SMG" more "how'd-they-think-of-that?" moments than a dozen of its competitors — combined.

4. "Mass Effect": BioWare's latest role-playing game lets you explore one of the most elaborate science-fiction universes ever created, in a fascinating galactic chase that requires you to make some real moral choices.

5. "Rock Band": Add drums and a microphone to the "Guitar Hero" formula and you have the best multiplayer game of the year. Huge props to developer Harmonix for landing songs from an excellent cross-section of real-life rockers, from Metallica to The Clash.

6. "Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3": I'm a sucker for old-school, turn-based role-playing games, and this was the year's best, adding a disturbing story and — of all things — a dating simulator.

7. "Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare": The venerable combat series leaves World War II behind and moves into the 21st century — but still sets the standard for first-person shooters.

8. "Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords": Mixing a puzzle game with a role-playing fantasy sounds like a terrible idea until it's 4 a.m. and all you want to do is just fight one more ogre.

9. "Zack & Wiki: Quest for Barbaros' Treasure": Don't let the cute characters fool you: This throwback to the graphic adventures of the '80s and '90s offers some of the toughest brainteasers around.

10. "The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass": Nintendo showed everyone else how to make a great DS game with another brilliant chapter in its "Zelda" cycle.

—THE REST OF THE BEST: A few other games that didn't make it into my top 10 deserve some mention:

Best game that almost seems like an afterthought: "Portal," the innovative puzzle game that rounded out Electronic Arts' "Half-Life 2" omnibus, "The Orange Box."

Best Xbox Live Arcade game: "Catan," Big Huge Games' slick adaptation of the classic board game "Settlers of Catan."

Best TV-based game: "The Simpsons Game."

Best game-based TV: "South Park," for its tributes to "World of Warcraft" and "Guitar Hero."

Best new character: "Eternal Sonata" protagonist Frederic Chopin — yes, the legendary Polish composer.

Best trend: Games go mainstream, thanks largely to Nintendo's Wii and DS. Even your grandma has joined a Wii bowling league.

—THANKS, SANTA: Of course, a lot of Christmas shoppers are still having trouble finding the Wii. So Nintendo is offering the next best thing: a rain check that will ensure buyers that they get the hot console before Jan. 29.

GameStop, the nation's largest chain of video-game stores, will be selling the rain checks at the regular Wii system price, $249.99, this Thursday and Friday.

GameStop has also opened its first "tournament store," a 4,000-square-foot facility in San Jose, Calif.

GameStop said the store, which features 24 networked gaming stations connected to plasma televisions, will host tournaments most weekends.

It opened with a "Madden NFL 08" competition, with the winner receiving a $1,000 GameStop shopping spree.

—NEW IN STORES: The last major game of the holiday season is "Nights: Journey of Dreams" (Sega, for the Wii), the long-awaited sequel to the cult favorite "Nights Into Dreams." ...

Electronic Arts and MTV Games' "Rock Band" comes to the PlayStation 2. Now where's the Wii version? ...

And THQ delivers the latest edition of its off-road racing series, "MX vs. ATV Untamed" (Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, PS2, PlayStation Portable, Nintendo DS). No sleigh-driving option, alas.

Von Fox glaube ich.

Here's our annual look at the best and worst in video games, 2007 edition.

------ BEST GAME: "BioShock." A first-person shooter turned morality play, a thinking person's action game, a piece of electronic fiction with a soul. There are many positive ways to describe this gripping game and they're all true. There's just nothing else like this eerie vision of an undersea social experiment gone horribly wrong. Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, Windows PC, $59.99, Rated M.

------ BEST DEAL: The Orange Box. For $59.99, the innovators at Valve Corp. have provided one of the best bargains in 2007. You get five games, and all of them are excellent. "Portal," in particular, seems destined for legendary status, having spawned a cottage industry for plush companion cubes. (If you don't know what that means, you're really missing out). Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, Windows PC, $59.99, Rated T through M.

------ BEST GAME THAT INVOLVES GETTING OFF THE SOFA: "Rock Band." Close the windows, lock the doors and warn the neighbors before you blare the volume. "Rock Band" elevates music rhythm games to arena-filling levels in a game that gets better the more people there are. For a true rocking experience you'll at least need two guitars -- lead and bass -- plus a drummer and a singer to belt out the dozens of tunes. Groupies are optional.

------ WORST TREND: The annual holiday video game deluge. Please, video game makers, you're only hurting your most loyal fans here. We spend all year with hardly anything new to play, then October rolls around and it's like an avalanche. Suddenly, we're faced with tough decisions about which of the dozens of good games we can actually afford to buy. Why not release more of these gems in the winter, spring or summer doldrums, when we're really looking for -- and more able to afford -- something new?

------ MOST TIRING CONTROVERSY. "Manhunt 2." OK people, it seems pretty obvious that "Manhunt 2" is not a game for the kiddies. So why all the uproar? Ratings issues aside, if a game that lets you perform execution moves is a turnoff, change the channel. Parents have a tough job keeping content like this away from their children, but it's ultimately part of the responsibility. And this game is no more graphic than any number of R-rated movies I've seen -- except they aren't being altered to appeal to industry ratings groups.

------ BEST (AND WORST) TREND: First person shooters were back in a big way this year. From the sublime ("BioShock") to the visually stunning ("Crysis"), there are more ways to wield weapons in convincing three-dimensional worlds than ever before. That's the good news, particularly for console owners. PC owners, however, are going to need beefy systems costing many thousands of dollars to make these gorgeous games playable.

------ MOST OVERRATED GAME: "Halo 3." Yes, I went there. And I'm not saying "Halo 3" is bad. It's a decent game, with some good fighting and excellent online modes, no doubt. But don't believe Microsoft Corp.'s marketing and PR hype machine. Halo 3 changes nothing about video games. "Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare" has a more interesting multiplayer component. And "Halo 3's" single-player story is baffling and leaves this supposedly epic saga feeling somewhat incomplete.

------ BEST IDEA FOR A GAME GONE HORRIBLY WRONG. "Lair." Seriously, this PlayStation 3 game looks so awesome yet plays so horribly, it's like a sick joke from the developers. You're supposed to use the PS3's motion-sensitive controller to pilot your very own fire-breathing, butt-kicking dragon. Unfortunately, moving the controller left to move your dragon left, for example, is fairly impossible. Don't even get me started on 180-degree turns. I'm sure with practice you'll gain some semblance of control, but most people will give up in frustration long before they ever reach that point.

------ MOST FRUSTRATING DELAYS: If I can't get my hands on blockbusters like "Metal Gear Solid IV: Guns of the Patriots," "Spore" or "Grand Theft Auto IV" soon, I think I'm going to lose it. Production delays are common in the games industry, and they're generally a good thing in the long run. The extra time only makes for a better, hopefully bug-free, gaming experience. But we've been hearing about these titles for like, ever, and I'm frankly getting very impatient.

Here's hoping all these games become a reality in 2008.

Con ABC oder wie auch immer das hieß.

 

[coke501(tm)]

Am besten find ich best Sidekick von Gamespy: Companion Cube... Ich liebe übrigens Portal

 

[Hanno]

"2. "Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction"

3. "Super Mario Galaxy":"

Gnihi, das ist mutig. Ist zwar "nur" Fox, aber ich freu' mich ehrlich über Platz 9 für Zack&Wiki

 

[Sellerie]

Gamespy Awards

Best Soundtrack: Mass Erect

Ist der Witz von dir oder von Gamespy?
Ist bestimmt nurn Test obs überhaupt jemand ganz liest. :-D

 

[Mahlzeit]

Eurogamer hat gewählt:

1 Portal
2 SMG
3 Bioshock
4 Crackdown
5 Zelda phantom Hourglass
6 COD 4
7 Halo 3
8 Mass effect
9 Team Fortress 2
10 Stalker

http://www.eurogamer.net/article.php?article_id=89793

Edit: Plätze 50-11:

50 Stuntman Ignition
49 Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter 2
48 Virtua Tennis 3
47 SEGA Rally
46 Rock Band
45 The Lord of the Rings Online: Shadows of Angmar
44 **** Raider Anniversary
43 Catan
42 Final Fantasy Tactics: The War of the Lions
41 Picross DS
40 Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords
39 Super Paper Mario
38 Overlord
37 SingStar PS3
36 Lego Star Wars: The Complete Saga
35 Zack & Wiki: The Quest for Barbaros' Treasure
34 Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Trials And Tribulations
33 Half-Life 2: Episode Two
32 MotorStorm
31 Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock
30 Assassin's Creed
29 God Hand
28 Trauma Center: Second Opinion
27 God of War 2
26 Ratchet & Clank: Tools of Destruction
25 Bladestorm
24 Crysis
23 The Darkness
22 World in Conflict
21 World of Warcraft: The Burning Crusade
20 Earth Defence Force 2017
19 Skate
18 Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
17 Project Gotham Racing 4
16 Puzzle Series Vol. 5: Slitherlink
15 Okami
14 Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
13 Final Fantasy XII
12 Peggle Deluxe
11 Pac-Man: Championship Edition

 

[hoiji]

WTF Portal auf Platz 1...Mhhh, Sicherlich, das Game ist genial. Aber es ist mehr so ein exotische Snack für zwischen durch....

Und Crackdown auf der 4. Kann man sich des relativ platten Spielablaufes drüber streiten . Ich hatte jedenfall Unmengen an Fun mit dem Game. Mit Halo3, Zelda und momentan Mass Effect hab ich aber noch mehr Spass ^^.
Also schon irgendwie komisch der Platz...

EDIT: Platz 20

 

[tweaker06]

hier die wertungen der amn redakteure


Matt Furtado:

10) Zack & Wiki: Quest for Barbaros' Treasure (Wii)
9) The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass (DS)
8. Disgaea Afternoon of Darkness (PSP)
7) Heavenly Sword (PS3)
6) Ninja Gaiden Sigma (PS3)
5) Metroid Prime 3: Corruption (Wii)
4) Syphon Filter: Logan's Shadow (PSP)
3) Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (360, PS3)
2) Super Mario Galaxy (Wii)
1) BioShock (360)


Jeff Rivera:

10) Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords (DS)
9) Super Paper Mario (Wii)
8. Halo 3 (360)
7) Rock Band (360, PS3)
6) Metroid Prime 3: Corruption (Wii)
5) The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass (DS)
4) The Orange Box (360)
3) Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (360)
2) BioShock (360)
1) Super Mario Galaxy (Wii)


Phillip Levin:

10) World of Warcraft: Burning Crusade (PC)
9) Super Paper Mario (Wii)
8. Crackdown (360)
7) The Orange Box (360)
6) Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (360)
5) Mass Effect (360)
4) Halo 3 (360)
3) Metroid Prime 3: Corruption (Wii)
2) BioShock (360)
1) Super Mario Galaxy (Wii)


Ryan Olsen:

10) Everyday Shooter (PS3)
9) Calling All Cars (PS3)
8. fl0w (PS3)
7) Super Stardust HD (PS3)
6) Warhawk (PS3)
5) Heavenly Sword (PS3)
4) MotorStorm (PS3)
3) Folklore (PS3)
2) Eye of Judgment (PS3)
1) TIE: Ratchet and Clank + Uncharted (PS3)


Casey Ayer:

10) WarioWare: Smooth Moves (Wii)
9) Assassin's Creed (360)
8. John Woo Presents: Stranglehold (360)
7) Metroid Prime 3: Corruption (Wii)
6) The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass (DS)
5) Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock
4) Mass Effect (360)
3) The Orange Box (360)
2) Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (360)
1) Super Mario Galaxy (Wii)


Sascha Lichtenstein:

10) Crackdown (360)
9) Mass Effect (360)
8. Virtua Fighter 5 (360)
7) Halo 3 (360)
6) Ratchet & Clank Future: Tool of Destruction (PS3)
5) Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (360)
4) Uncharted: Drake's Fortune (PS3)
3) The Orange Box (360)
2) Super Mario Galaxy (Wii)
1) BioShock (360)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

man beachte die liste von Ryan Olsen^^ sehr objektiv der mann

ansonsten sind es ganz gute listen. die besten spiele des jahres sind fast alle dabei

 

[Howard]

Se ht euch mal Ryan Olsen an Wie geil :rofl: Bioshock und Galaxy die Gewinner.

 

[Swisslink]

Bioshock Platzierungen:
2x Erster
2x Zweiter
2x >10

Mario Galaxy:
3x Erster
2x Zweiter
1x >10

SMG >>>> Bioshock

 

[wsippel]

Gamespot

Super Mario Galaxy

Runners up:

Halo 3
Bioshock
World in Conflict
Orange Box
Call of Duty 4
Rock Band

Und vielleicht habe ich noch ein Spiel vergessen...

 

[Taddl]

Ryan Olsen:

10) Everyday Shooter (PS3)
9) Calling All Cars (PS3)
8. fl0w (PS3)
7) Super Stardust HD (PS3)
6) Warhawk (PS3)
5) Heavenly Sword (PS3)
4) MotorStorm (PS3)
3) Folklore (PS3)
2) Eye of Judgment (PS3)
1) TIE: Ratchet and Clank + Uncharted (PS3)

Und sowas darf als Redakteur in freier Wildbahn rumlaufen?

 

[Mahlzeit]

Und sowas darf als Redakteur in freier Wildbahn rumlaufen?

Sehr unabhängig!

 

[Mozzarella]

Und sowas darf als Redakteur in freier Wildbahn rumlaufen?

Darji wirds wohl nachvollziehen können.

 

[Krogan]

Lsst die Leute doch in Ruhe, er sieht es halt so und das sollte man auch akzeptieren.

 

[Nihilist]

Lsst die Leute doch in Ruhe, er sieht es halt so und das sollte man auch akzeptieren.

Kommt auf seine Artikel an.

Wenn die sich so lesen, wie seine GOTY Liste, dann würde ich ihn vor die Tür setzen. Gamsejournalisten sind schon fahrlässig genug, was ihre Artikel anbelangt, da braucht man keine offensichtlichen Fanboys mit duchfüttern.