Kinect vs. PlayStation Move vs. Wii Motion Plus (Neuer Versuch)

  • Thread-Ersteller Thread-Ersteller Calvin
  • Erstellungsdatum Erstellungsdatum

Welche Bewegungssteuerung hat euch überzeugt?


  • Stimmen insgesamt
    240
Why Kinect’s Future Is Brightest Of All

Now that the dust has settled and Kinect is out the door, it’s becoming quickly apparent that Microsoft’s motion controller is on to a bit of a roll. With sales surging and the big M talking down claims of enforced stock shortages in order to ramp up the peripherals desirability, no one could have honestly predicted we’d be here last E3…
With sales of Kinect doing all sorts of good business, we decided we should take a look at the real reasons why it’ll outlast and beat the competition…

kinect.jpg


It’s specifically targeted

Kinect isn’t for gamers. The Wii wasn’t for gamers. They’re specifically designed for people who don’t play games. Microsoft doesn’t need people who like Call Of Duty or Halo to buy an 360; clearly, you already have one. If the Xbox was to succeed and reach the kinds of numbers Nintendo’s Wii has been doing, it needed to reach out to a larger audience. Kinect works successfully here because, unlike Move, it doesn’t have any pretensions of being anything other than a game changer. Move still works with shooters and genres we’re all used to playing with a pad, but that’s an unnecessary concession. The Kinect has had laser like targeting and so, in the long run, audiences that don’t play games are already interested in the sorts of experiences Kinect can offer.

sports.jpg


They’re not really games

Another glaring issue; Kinect’s games are nearly totally removed from the sorts of experiences that have been the 360′s bread and butter for years. This is both a good and bad thing. When you take a look at titles like Get Fit With Mel B or Kinectimals the traditional ‘game’ template cannot be applied. Once again, this is appealing to all those people that gawp at Halo and COD with a condescending air. Kinect is the perfect peripheral in this regard, even more so than the Wii and Move – traditional experiences are almost impossible with Kinect. Its accuracy is enough for it to function, but inaccurate so that score attack games or anything that really requires ‘skill’ is made redundant. Kinect is more about the act of doing than the skill required to do it – perfect for families and people that shudder at the thought of spending time chasing an arbitrary number.

It looks like the future

Well it does. Where as the Move looks like a slightly advanced Wii, which we suppose in many ways it is, but that does totally ignores the improvements it makes. For the general public though, these perceptions don’t really matter, it’s what you can see in front of you that counts. When someone is moving a menu around like they’re in Minority Report, then that’s when people get excited. It’s also really easy to use with no confusing buttons, despite the on-screen menus becoming far more complicated and difficult to manoeuvre as a result.

adventures.jpg


In conclusion

Ultimately, Kinect’s success is down to the huge audience it attracts that have invested in it because of its potential. With no traditional game at launch, it should have been abundantly clear that Microsoft was entering into a much wider and considered market and we should stop looking at Kinect as something that will change our gaming lives. Perhaps a few games will come along to make us sit up and take notice, but for those of us that like gaming with a pad, Kinect won’t change this. But it will make Microsoft’s machine the home hub for everyone in the family, and that’s the reason Kinect has the brightest future of all the motion controllers.

http://www.360magazine.co.uk/community/why-kinects-future-is-brightest-of-all/
 
Der Kinect-Erfolg freut mich ehrlich für Microsoft, aber für mich persönlich wärs nix. Ich kann nur hoffen und glaube auch, das die Xbox "3" auch wieder ein Gamepad hat, wehe MS sonst wars das für mich, ich hab nämlich eure Xbox "3" fest im Käuferblick.:fight:
 
Oh, wie schnell Kinect wohl bei mir vom Wohnzimmer zum Schreibtisch wandern wird? :awesome:
[video=youtube;nr8vgCnb9_0]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nr8vgCnb9_0&feature=player_embedded[/video]
 
Soso, einzelne Move Controller also restlos ausverkauft :sorry:

JpvNW.jpg


Ich weiß, vergessen die Vorräte unterm Tisch zu fotografieren :Fuuu: War so im Elan :awesome:
Kinect hat sich aber auch gestapelt, beim Kinect Stand war aber dank einer Promoterin ordentlich was los (die sah aus wie Sternchen :nerd:, hatte aber keine Ahnung: "Genau damit er deine Hand erkennt musst du jetzt hüpfen :sorry:" xD )
 
Soso, einzelne Move Controller also restlos ausverkauft :sorry:

JpvNW.jpg


Ich weiß, vergessen die Vorräte unterm Tisch zu fotografieren :Fuuu: War so im Elan :awesome:
Kinect hat sich aber auch gestapelt, beim Kinect Stand war aber dank einer Promoterin ordentlich was los (die sah aus wie Sternchen :nerd:, hatte aber keine Ahnung: "Genau damit er deine Hand erkennt musst du jetzt hüpfen :sorry:" xD )

Ähm, das da sind doch Nav-Controller und keine Move-Controller? ;)
 
Ähm, das da sind doch Nav-Controller und keine Move-Controller? ;)
Ah Shit, hab ich das falsche fotografiert? :ugly:
Afaik ist das rechte obere einer, hab schnell gemacht weil der eine Typ komisch geguckt hat :ugly:

Sie waren aber wirklich en masse da, morgen bin ich vielleicht nochmal was umtauschen, dann mach ich nochmal eins ;)
 
Ah Shit, hab ich das falsche fotografiert? :ugly:
Afaik ist das rechte obere einer, hab schnell gemacht weil der eine Typ komisch geguckt hat :ugly:

Sie waren aber wirklich en masse da, morgen bin ich vielleicht nochmal was umtauschen, dann mach ich nochmal eins ;)

mach dann auch ein Foto von der Promoterin, von der du geredet hast :D ^^
 
Air Guitar Prototype with Kinect

airguitar.jpg


As noted in varying online sources, Chris O’Shea has created a rather innovative new Air Guitar Prototype utilizing the XBox Kinect
While I haven’t been much of a proponent of the Xbox Kinect since launch, this little tidbit of tech/gaming innovation shows some incredible options and advancements soon to be implemented and used with the Kinect platform.

http://www.sempercog.com/?p=1323
 
Kinect jetzt schon in über 4 Millionen Haushalten?

http://gamrfeed.vgchartz.com/story/83079/kinect-sales-reach-4-million-units-worldwide/

This puts Kinect on pace to sell over 6 million units by the end of the year.
Xbox360 hardware sales have seen a significant lift since the launch of Kinect with around 40% of all Kinect sensor sales worldwide coming via units bundled with Xbox360 hardware - clearly showing that Kinect has been selling outside of the existing Xbox360 userbase.
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
Source: MS quadrupling Kinect accuracy

Microsoft is working to improve the accuracy of Xbox 360 motion-sensing add-on Kinect so that it could detect finger movement and hand rotation, Eurogamer understands.

Microsoft's Kinect team is said to be working "very hard" on a switching or compression technology that will allow a greater amount of data to pass through Kinect to the Xbox 360 console.

Kinect features are dictated by firmware so that they can be added and upgraded over time.

The depth sensor used by Kinect is also dictated by firmware – it is currently set at a 30 frames per second limit and a 320x240 resolution limit.

At a 640x480 resolution, however, Kinect could begin to detect fingers and hand rotation – an effective quadrupling of its accuracy.

The issue relates to the USB controller interface, Eurogamer was told. It is capable of around 35MB/s, but it only uses around 15/16MB/s.

This artificial limit is in place because multiple USB devices can be used at once on an Xbox 360. But Microsoft is working on a technology to allow greater throughput in this regard, Eurogamer understands.

If Microsoft achieves its goal it could double the spec of Kinect's depth camera with a simple dashboard update.

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2010-12-17-source-ms-quadrupling-kinect-accuracy
 
Verdoppeln wohl eher nicht, aber ein Virtel oder sogar Drittel sollte man schon rausholen können wenn ich mir die PCler so angucke.
 
Verdoppeln wohl eher nicht, aber ein Virtel oder sogar Drittel sollte man schon rausholen können wenn ich mir die PCler so angucke.

steht da nicht sogar vervierfachen?

jedenfalls hat ms mit kinect nen volltreffer gelandet ... bei den casuals.
es wird immer ausgereiftere software kommen und sobald die noch was mit dem preis machen und mal werbung schalten, wird das teil denke ich auch in europa einschlagen.

gegen kinect sehen die ganzen casual games auf der wii oder ps3 ziemlich last gen aus, was man vor allem bei tanzspielen sieht.
 
Zuletzt bearbeitet:
Zurück
Top Bottom